I like the new
rule allowing teams to appeal calls by umpires regarding home runs. The umps check the replay to see whether a home
run ball is fair or foul or above or below a HR line in some parks.
While we don't want the games delayed unnecessarily, the goal should be
to get the call right. Video replay is used in basketball and football
so why not take advantage of the technology in baseball.
Changes in baseball should not stop with the replay policy. There are some rules that almost every serious baseball fan knows are dumb and should be changed. My biggest scoring pet peeve is the concept that you can't anticipate a double play. According to MLB.com Official Info, errors are dealt with by Official Rule 10.12. Specifically, Rule 10.12(d) states that "the official scorer shall not charge an error against: ... (3) any fielder who makes a wild throw in attempting to complete a double play or triple play, unless such throw enables any runner to advance beyond the base such runner would have reached had the throw not been wild." (a comment follows that an error will be charged if a good throw which would have put the runner out is dropped.) So, as long as the batter/runner doesn't advance to 2nd base, no error is charged to the fielder making the wild throw in an attempt to complete a double play.
Hey, this is not little league, high school or college ball I'm talking about. Major League ball players are supposed to make all the routine plays. When they fail to, they should be charged with errors. I can understand
not charging an error if the fielder was about to be taken out by the
runner and had to rush his throw. But when there's plenty of time, an error
should be charged if in the scorer's judgment the batter would have
been out.
Situation: Runner on first with 1 out and slow runner at the plate. A hard hit ball just to the left of second base is fielded cleanly by the shortstop. He steps on second and, despite having plenty of time, throws wildly to first, allowing the batter/runner to reach safely. The runner on first base was not bearing down on the shortstop.The batter/runner would have been out by ten feet with a good throw. If the next batter hits a home run, the pitcher is charged with 2 earned runs even though the batter/runner should have been out. If the rule is changed to allow the official scorer to charge the shortstop with a throwing error, the pitcher is only charged with 1 earned run if the next batter homers.
In the above situation, if the shortstop's wild throw to first enabled the batter/runner to reach 2nd base, the shortstop gets charged with an error. This doesn't help the pitcher if the next batter hits a HR. Since the error was charged for allowing the runner to advance an extra base rather than for failing to get the out at 1st base, the pitcher still gets charged with 2 earned runs. Earned Run Averages are much higher than when I started following baseball in the mid 1950's. According to espn.com stats, after 45 games this season the A/L teams are averaging a 4.59 era while the DH-less N/L is at 4.39. The hitters haven't needed any more help since the pitching mound was lowered for the 1969 season. Since I don't believe there's any movement to restore the height of the mound, maybe some changes in official scoring rules would give some small solace to pitchers with soaring era's.
Another change that could help a bit would be to allow the official scorer to charge a "team error" where a play should have been made but it's difficult to assign the error to one particular fielder. This concept has been proposed before and rejected but I still believe it has a lot of merit. A pitcher makes a great pitch that the batter pops up. The ball drops between 2 or 3 players, any one of whom could easily make the catch. If the scorer can't decide who to give the error to, he takes the easy way out and gives the batter a hit. Giving the team an error would solve the problem. It seems to me that in most cases, if there's a questionable call as to whether a batted ball is to be scored a hit or an error, the call usually favors the batter.