The 150th anniversary of the beginning of the Civil War occurred a week ago on April 12th. On that day in 1861 the Confederates fired on Fort Sumter to begin a war which would ultimately claim over 618,000 lives. In the past fifteen years, I've read a fair amount of history and historical fiction about the Civil War and related events. Before then, the only Civil War books I can recall with certainty reading were Stephen Crane's "Red Badge of Courage" and Bruce Catton's "This Hallowed Ground". I vaguely recall reading a book about Robert E. Lee but can't remember the title. Most of us know the basic facts about the war but are a little hazy about the details. For a lot of us, it's been many years since we took American history in high school or college. What follows is a list of books I've read about the war that can fill in some of those details. In parenthesis I've included the year of publication and length. There are plenty of reviews on line that you can read rather than just take my recommendation.
Although I've been a resident of a southern state for the past 4 1/2 years, it hasn't changed my opinion about the conflict. I'm reminded though of a former co-worker and fellow New Yorker who moved to Georgia. One of his young sons asked him one day "Daddy, why did we lose the Civil War?". Shortly after moving to Nashville, I decided to read historian Shelby Foote's three volume history, "The Civil War: A Narrative", to get a southern perspective. I had read reviews that credited his work as fair minded and I think it was. Foote's history is a long read but well written. Volume I is called "Fort Sumter to Perryville" (810 pgs - 1958), Volume II "Fredericksburg to Meridian" (966 pgs - 1963) and Volume III "Red River to Appomattox" (1,060 pgs - 1974). Foote became well known when he appeared on the Ken Burns PBS documentary, The Civil War.
Stephen B. Oates began a Civil War Trilogy called "Voices of the Storm". Volume I, "The Approaching Fury, 1820 - 1861" (512 pgs - 1998) provided the events leading to the war; Volume II, "The Whirlwind of War, 1861 - 1865" (864 pgs - 1999) covered the war itself. The third volume was supposed to cover the reconstruction period but has not appeared as yet. The first two volumes were excellent. Oates has the characters - John Calhoun, John Brown, Lincoln, etc. - speaking in the first person about their lives and events. Oates was also one of the commentators on the Ken Burns documentary. He had previously written the excellent full length biography "With Malice Towards None: A Life of Abraham Lincoln" and "Fires of Jubilee: Nat Turner's Fierce Rebellion".
Speaking of Lincoln, I would also highly recommend "Team of Rivals, The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln" (2005 - 754 pgs) by Doris Kearns Goodwin. Lincoln's team of "Rivals" included William H. Seward, Salmon P. Chase, Edwin M. Stanton and Edward Bates.
"Lincoln" (1995 - 599 pgs) by David Donald is another great read. It's a cradle to the grave bio but mercifully doesn't dwell for long on the front end.
Michael Kauffman's "American Brutus, John Wilkes Booth and the Lincoln Conspiracies" (2004 - 398 pgs) is very interesting. Kauffman's take on the responsibility for the assassination makes a lot of sense.
"LIncoln at Gettysburg, The Words That Remade America" (1992 - 189 pgs) by Garry Wills is a Pulitzer Prize winner about the Gettyburg Address.
Since we're talking Gettysburg, Michael Shaara's historical novel "The Killer Angels" (1974 - 355 pgs), also a Pulitzer Prize winner, has been called the best historical novel about war.
Michael died in 1988 but his son Jeff Shaara has taken up where dad left off with books like "Gods and Generals" (1996 - 498 pgs), the prequel, and "The Last Full Measure" (2000 - 640 pgs), the sequel, to his father's "The Killer Angels".
"Cloudsplitter" by Russell Banks is a historical novel about John Brown (1998 - 758 pgs). The story is told from the perspective of Owen Brown, the last surviving son of John Brown. Banks has written many novels and also writes short stories. "Trailerpark" is my favorite collection.
Harriet Beecher Stowe's "Uncle Tom's Cabin" (1852 - 447 pgs) needs no commentary.
Ambrose Bierce's "Tales of Soldiers" are short stories of an anti-war nature, emphasizing the horrors of war. Bierce, also the author of the Devil's Dictionary, served as a soldier in the Civil War. Good stuff.
Jeffrey Wert - "General James Longstreet" (1994 - 528 pgs) After reading about Gettysburg, a book about Lee's second in charge seemed like a natural followup.
Other Civil War books I would recommend in roughly descending order:
Stephen Sears - "Chancellorsville" (1998 - 640 pgs)
Geoffrey Perret - "Ulysses S. Grant, Soldier & President" (1997 - 542 pgs)
Brian Steel Wills - "A Battle From the Start: The Life of Nathan Bedford Forest" (1992 - 457 pgs)
John Bowers - "Stonewall Jackson, Portrait of a Soldier" (1990 - 360 pgs )
Roy Morris, Jr. - "Sheridan: The Life and Wars of General Phil Sheridan" (1992 - 542 pgs)
Stanley Hirshon - "White Tecumseh, Biography of William Tecumseh Sherman" (1998 - 475 pgs)
Robert Hicks - "The Widow of the South" (2005 - 432 pgs)
Charles Frazier - "Cold Mountain" (1997 - 449 pgs)
Laurence Hauptman - "Between Two Fires, American Indians in the Civil War" (1995 - 304 pgs)
Jack Coombe - "Thunder Along the Mississippi, River Battles that Split the Confederacy" (1996 - 260 pgs)
William Fletcher - "Rebel Private: Front and Rear: Memoirs of a Confederate Soldier" (1997 - 240 pgs)
James Street - "The Civil War, An Unvarnished Account of the Last but Still Lively Hostilities" (1953 - 144 pgs)
Richard Harwell (editor) - "The Confederate Reader: How the South Saw the War" (1989 - 416 pgs)
I should read:
Number one on my "to read" list is the Pulitzer Prize winning "Battle Cry of Freedom, The Civil War Era" by James McPherson, a one volume history (862 pgs) published in 1988. I bought the book over 10 years ago while I was still working. My lame excuse for not reading it then was that it was too heavy to lug around. I did much of my reading back then on the LIRR to and from Penn Station. As a retiree, I no longer have that excuse.
George R. Stewart - "Pickett's Charge" (1959 - 384 pages). I read and really enjoyed two other Stewart books, "Names on the Land, A Historical Account of Place-Naming in the United States" and "The California Trail".
What books about the Civil War would you recommend?
When my wife and I visited Gettysburg in September of 2005, one of the things that stood out for me was the site of Pickett's charge, the confederate assault on Cemetery Ridge. Imagine being one of the soldiers leading the charge. You're moving across an open field, uphill toward a well barricaded enemy. I would have been terrified. It was nothing less than a suicide mission.